Menu of Vince Anna's Restaurant (Reservations Required) in Greenville, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Vince Anna's Restaurant in Greenville, NY, stands as a beacon of classic Italian cuisine, offering a menu steeped in tradition yet delivered with an inviting freshness. The establishment, known for requiring reservations, cultivates an intimate dining experience that allows the kitchen to focus on quality and consistency.

At the heart of Vince Anna’s menu lies their Chicken Parmigiana, a dish that drew widespread praise, notably from diners like Matthew Ryan who declared it “the best chicken parm I’ve ever had.” The chicken is perfectly breaded, crisp on the outside, tender inside, and generously smothered in a rich tomato sauce and melted cheese—a timeless comfort food executed with precision.

The Spaghetti and Meatballs and Lemon Chicken are other highlights — both embodying traditional Italian flavors with balanced seasoning and fresh ingredients. These dishes showcase the chef’s respect for classic recipes, something that regular patrons like Sue Rysedorph consistently appreciate.

Seafood lovers will find joy in the Deep Fried Shrimp and Scallops and the Seafood Steak, which marry freshness with a delicate, crispy texture. These selections stand out as hearty yet refined options that elevate the coastal Italian dining experience.

Pizza aficionados should not overlook Vince Anna’s Pepperoni Pizza. It carries an old-school charm with a perfectly blistered crust and a generous pepperoni topping, epitomizing the "throwback atmosphere" praised by guests such as Kevin M.

Further enhancing the meal are the thoughtfully curated appetizers, baked pastas, and side options, all designed to complement the main courses without overpowering them. To finish, indulge in their Parfait, a sweet finale that balances richness and freshness, sealing the dining experience with a touch of elegance.

The ambiance is a warm throwback to a bygone era, with a spacious open layout and a comfortable deck area that invites relaxed conversation. Service here is one of Vince Anna's strongest suits—staff are consistently described as friendly, efficient, and attentive, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere cherished by locals and newcomers alike.

While some may find certain dishes leaning towards traditional rather than revolutionary, Vince Anna's retains its charm through consistency, hospitality, and a genuine love for Italian cooking. For those willing to make the drive or secure reservations ahead of time, Vince Anna’s offers an authentic and hearty Italian dining experience that continues to earn loyal fans and heartfelt reviews.